Day 525 – confusion reigns

S&P 500 Decline
9-Nov-07 1565
9-Mar-09 676 57%
18-Mar-09 778 50%

Well as the above math indicates, the markets have improved so now they are  fully half of what they once were.

There are so many opinions/recipes/predictions for fixing the financial system:

Do Mark to Market assets on company balance sheets to improve visibility and certainty about earnings; or

Don’t mark to market assets as these add to volatility in earnings and in the end are estimates only

Buy equities, the recession is ending in 2009; or

Do nothing, the recession is deeper than expected and mid 2010 is the earliest relief point

Since the public purse is bailing out AIG (Citigroup, Bank America…) the new owners should protect us by reneging on employee bonuses. The principle is one of fairness to those who are preventing these companies from disappearing entirely; or

Pay the bonuses, keeping the companies whole will pay off in the future as a more valuable asset is sold. These bonuses represent insignificant dollar values

New expanded monetary policy is helpful in the short term and disastrous later; or

The US economy is expected to drive world recovery, the reasonable  cost of this effort is more US dollars in circulation

I expect many of you find all of these conflicting views compelling even as they are source of argument. I  usually find both sides of the noise plausible and somewhat meaningless as a result. The loudest opinion is unlikely to be the most helpful, or best considered. In times as these, we need to have some reasonable basis for  making investment decisions.

There seems to be a quest to define the moment of inertia, when the economy begins to grow instead of shrink.  If we could guess the day what would we do exactly? Search for a new job… buy an investment property? Maybe we could pick that exact moment to buy stocks in our retirement accounts.

Unfortunately,  we would probably be late to the party for stock markets.   If we look at the most severe recessions in the past 40 years for Japan, UK, US and Germany at the official end of each recession the local stock market had rebounded from a low of 31% in US markets in March of 1975 to a high of 137% in the UK in December of 1975. Of course the end of recessions are defined by looking back 6 months. Not helpful if you are trying to time a stock entry point or major purchase.

Good judgement starts with clearly understanding your unique situation. Investment activities should be added to after accounting for and funding cash requirements and perhaps reducing debt. In this way you will not be forced to turn what should be a positive into a negative investment experience.

Print, Share, Subcribe or Forward
  • Print this article!
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Turn this article into a PDF!

One Response to “Day 525 – confusion reigns”

  1. wonker says:

    Interesting blog, I’ll try and spread the word.

Leave a Comment